Ale & Tale Tavern, developed by Scienart Games, arrived on Steam this September, bringing a delightful mix of tavern management, adventure, and quirky fantasy. As a fan of cozy games and fantasy sims, I dove headfirst into this tavern-builder with high expectations—after all, running your own hearth in a whimsical world sounds like the perfect way to unwind.
I personally had high hopes for the game during my D&D phase. And after spending some time with the game, I’m glad to report that it ticked all the boxes. That said, it wasn’t without its flaws, so let’s break down what makes Ale & Tale Tavern tick and the cobwebs it could clean up.
Pros:
- Beautiful, immersive world
- Cozy, satisfying tavern management
- Great co-op mode
- Engaging crafting and gathering systems
Cons:
- Limited to first-person view
- Repetitive quest structure
- Rough voice acting
- NPCs can become tiresome
The Good, The Whimsy, and The Potential
One of the first things that stood out about Ale & Tale Tavern is the sheer amount of customization options available during character creation. You can dress your character in a myriad of outfits, from standard tavern keeper garb to more absurd combinations (I’m looking at you, bucket-on-head lingerie combo). While I kept it simple for my first playthrough, I can easily see players experimenting with wackier choices for their tavern-running journey.
“Isolated at the start, but slowly presents more mysteries to explore..“
The game’s graphics are charming, with a colorful, slightly stylized aesthetic that’s reminiscent of World of Warcraft. The idyllic woodland around your tavern feels isolated at the start, but slowly presents more mysteries to explore. And the night sky is particularly beautiful, adding a touch of magic to your evening shifts.
Ale & Tale Tavern introduces its mechanics through a questline that acts as both tutorial and guide. You’ll start by talking to a merchant NPC who will help you get your bearings—though it’s worth noting that the game’s early instructions are a bit unclear. For example, to purchase items from the merchant, you don’t click on the character itself but rather the cash register next to them, which took me a few minutes to figure out. It’s a small thing, but moments like this can throw you off in the early hours.
Ale and Tale: Help Wanted
The heart of Ale & Tale Tavern lies in managing your humble tavern—decorating it, keeping things clean, serving customers, and cooking meals. At first, it’s simple enough: You start with a few basic recipes and drinks, and your primary task is to serve patrons and keep your pub running smoothly. There’s a satisfying rhythm to it, and as you progress, new recipes and ingredients unlock, expanding your culinary repertoire.
One of the game’s standout features is its system for gathering ingredients. You can grow your own crops, forage for herbs, hunt wildlife, and even brew your own potions and elixirs. This adds a nice layer of depth to the tavern experience, as you’re not just making meals with ingredients you buy—you’re actively sourcing them from the world around you. It’s an immersive and engaging system that encourages exploration.
“The gameplay loop, while satisfying at first, begins to show its cracks after extended sessions.“
However, as the game progresses, the need for a larger variety of ingredients starts to feel like a grind. To keep up with the increasing demands of your customers and quests, you’ll spend a lot of time hunting down specific ingredients in the surrounding environment. While this adds to the adventuring aspect, it also feels extremely repetitive. I spent long stretches of time chasing down elusive creatures or gathering rare herbs, only to return to my tavern to serve customers for a few minutes before repeating the cycle. The gameplay loop, while satisfying at first, begins to show its cracks after extended sessions.
The Co-Op Experience Is Where Ale & Tale Shines
One of the most exciting features of Ale & Tale Tavern is its co-op mode, which was the best part of my game review. Running a tavern on your own can quickly become overwhelming. Without any in-game help, you’ll be juggling multiple tasks at once: cooking, serving, cleaning, and managing customer orders. While this is manageable early on, it becomes increasingly difficult as your tavern grows. This is where having a friend—or two—really helps.
In co-op mode, tasks can be delegated among players, allowing for a much smoother experience. While one player gathers ingredients, another can focus on cooking or tending to the customers. It creates a fun, dynamic rhythm where everyone has a role, and the game feels way more fun and manageable. Without this co-op option, the game could easily become a tedious grind, so I firmly believe this is the way Ale and Tale was meant to be played: with friends.
The Downsides of Medieval Customer Service
Unfortunately, Ale & Tale Tavern isn’t without its drawbacks. One of the most significant issues is the decision to limit the game to a first-person perspective, with no option for third-person view. For some players, this won’t be an issue, but I found it personally hard to stomach. As someone who tends to get motion sickness in first-person games, I had to play in small doses to avoid feeling nauseous.
It’s a shame because I believe the game could have benefited from a wider perspective, especially considering the beautiful world it presents.
“The quest structure is repetitive, and I found myself rushing past certain dialogue sections just to get back to the tavern management aspect of the game.”
Another area that could use some improvement is the NPC interactions. While the characters you meet are eccentric and fun, the voice acting is a bit rough. I appreciate the effort to include voice work, but it’s clear that some of the performances are amateurish. The NPC dialogue also leans heavily on repeating the same jokes or themes, which become tiresome real quick. For example, a scarecrow NPC spends much of his dialogue talking about “magic weed,” which, while funny at first, grows old quickly.
Lastly, the quests often felt like tedious fetch tasks, which forced me to run across the map to collect items for NPCs. The writing is amusing at times, but the quest structure is repetitive, and I found myself rushing past certain dialogue sections just to get back to the tavern management aspect of the game, which is the real highlight.
7/10 – A Crackling Hearth with Room for Improvement
Ale & Tale Tavern is a charming and cozy game that does a lot of things right. The tavern management systems are satisfying, and the world has a good chunk to explore. The co-op mode is a standout feature, turning what could’ve been a tedious singleplayer run into a fun fantasy sim. The game shines when it sticks to its core gameplay loop of gathering, cooking, and managing your tavern.
However, the repetitive nature of the quests, the lack of third-person perspective, and the occasionally frustrating NPC interactions prevent Ale & Tale Tavern from being a perfect experience. That said, it’s still an enjoyable and relaxing game that’s perfect for fans of cozy sims—just be prepared for some relatively grindy moments and offbeat NPCs.
If you’re looking for a lighthearted, immersive tavern sim with the potential for great co-op fun, Ale & Tale Tavern is definitely worth checking out. Just be prepared to spend a little more time gathering ingredients than you might expect.
Ale & Tale Tavern is now available to play on PC and Steam!
Visit Geekmandem for the latest gaming news!
