There has been a sudden revitalization of a lot of series taking place in the game industry the past few years.  For the most part it is great to see long desired sequels like Diablo 3 finally coming to fruition but along with the idea to follow up on games that fans love is the idea to cash in on the exact same thing once again by slapping HD on the end of the title.  These are called “HD remakes”.

Basically what an HD remake usually entails is upping the resolution and tweaking the graphics so the character models are smoother and the levels have more detail.  They can be a good step-up from the original versions but for many of them they do look fairly similar.  None of them look like they were made for this generation of consoles (excluding the Wii of course).  They also increase the frame-rate in some cases so that the game runs better.  At first these were being used as a way to increase awareness for an upcoming release.  For instance when God of War 3 was coming out Sony released an HD collection that featured the first two God of War games in HD for $40 to get new people into the series and maybe get some fans to repurchase the games.  This is no longer the case, now many companies just see it as an easy opportunity to make some money.  One of my problems with this is that it takes time to convert the games into HD but they don’t need to.  The games from last generation are still playable.  They don’t look good by today’s standard, but they aren’t hard to look at and understand either.  When I look at something from the PS1 or N64 there are objects that are hard to make out and people look weird but that isn’t really an issue with something like God of War.  Plus it isn’t a total remake so what’s the point in repurchasing?

This leads to another issue.  If the graphical upgrades aren’t needed then why do we have to pay so much for these games and make such a big deal about them when we could just purchase the games on PSN or Xbox Live for less.  Both Xbox Live and the PSN have older games for purchase, so why release certain ones in stores and others online.  In fact Sony spends so much time talking about HD remakes I didn’t know that you could buy PS2 games on PSN until this week when I searched around on Google.  They should just put the majority of their respective libraries (not all because some companies have closed and can’t put them up and some might not want to) online for $15 (like an arcade game) and give package deals for $30, which shaves 25% off the price tag right there.  It also allows people to get specific games in a series they might have missed instead of forcing them to buy the whole series.  Not to mention that it would give gamers the chance to pick up games they missed for a fairly good price when you consider that the games won’t be damaged and they won’t have to rely on some guy online to send them the right thing.  There are so many great games that go overlooked and if Sony and Microsoft did this and spent time advertising it, maybe some of those games could finally get the recognition they deserve.  So while I appreciate the fact that HD remakes are keeping certain games alive, instead of allowing everyone just move on and forget about them, it shouldn’t be limited to just the big games from successful companies that don’t need the extra cash.  Another bonus is that it won’t be putting new games in direct competition on shelves with classics.  The Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection was billed as one of Sony’s biggest games this fall which isn’t fair for new games coming out for that console, because their developers have put way more time and money into new products to have the sales taken away by re-releases of classics.

We used to get remakes of classic games ported over to the handhelds so that we would have something good to play on them like all of the Final Fantasy ports.  Now we port PS2 games to the PS3.  The PS3 has quality games and the teams should focus on them instead of going for the easy money with these HD remakes.  Plus for the record the 60GB PS3 that came out at launch can play every PS2 game and as I wrote above you don’t need them to be in HD to thoroughly enjoy them.  The 80GB model which I have (this too is a launch model) can play most PS2 games like God of War and FFX (both of which Sony decided to put in HD).  The reason the new models can’t is because Sony wanted you to focus on the PS3 games so they striped a feature out and are trying to get you to buy it back one game at a time, which to be honest is BS.  If you are going to remake a game that has a large fan base and try to get people to buy it again, at least do it justice and give them a real reason for picking it back up. Look at 343 industries and the Halo: CE Anniversary game.  They didn’t redesigning the game (which they probably should have since I prefer Halo 2, but then it would have been full priced), but they gave it a new graphical coat so that it looks like it belongs on the 360 (mind you an early 360 game, but a 360 game none the less) and let you flip back and forth between the new and original look on the fly.  It also comes with bonus maps based on classic Halo 1&2 maps to be included in Reach so you get more than just the game.  If Sony wants to cash in on its classic franchises just remake FFVII from the ground up to look like FFXIII.  One of my other problems with HD remakes is that it takes up time that the developers should be using to improve the next game they are releasing or to come up with something new.  The Ico & Shadow collection was an entire year of work for a portion of a small company that should have been spent working on The Last Guardian which hasn’t really been seen at al since they announced their HD remake.

So while I appreciate the idea that we aren’t just moving from one thing to the next, but taking time to look back at some of the great games that brought us to where we are, I think it would be better to just make the majority of the Xbox and PS2 libraries available through Xbox Live and PSN and look back at everything, not just a choose few.  Then they can put the advertising into the service instead of each specific remake.  This would allow people to find and play whatever they want quickly and easily, adding another incentive for those who don’t yet have the consoles by offering two libraries of games instead of one. It also allows new games that smaller companies are making to do better by not competing with established blockbusters in stores. Plus the big companies can focus on making new games that we are all waiting for.  All of that and the fact that the tweaks aren’t necessary is why I have a problem with the HD remakes trend that everyone wants to cash in on.

17 Comments »

  1. Of all the things to complain about the game industry this isn’t one of them. The reason for hd remakes is believe it or not there are people that don’t have the previous system/game for whatever reason. So instead of buying another system & game (not everyone wants fifteen systems under their tv). They can purchase the hd remake an enjoy the games. If the price is to high wait a while as it will eventually go down.

  2. A very good article although I have to agree w/ Ben, but in a slightly different light. To begin, I bought the ICO/SotC Collection, both GoW Collections, and the MGS HD Collection. I also have the original PS2 & PSP games. So why did I buy the HD Remakes if I have the originals? Other than the simple “because I can” response, when I purchased those games, I was a frugal teenage gamer who always bought used. So the dev’s never saw my money. Call it brown-nosing the devs, but I feel that purchasing the HD remakes was my redemption…when I purchase these remakes, they now have the money that was rightfully theirs. Games such as Ico & SotC weren’t necessarily commercial successes, and this gave them that second chance to be. Ironically, I’ve seen used PS2 versions of ICO sell for $40 (USED!) at most local retailers. That’s the same price as the HD collection, so its really a no-brainer.

    And for the sake of supporting your article, yes, they could have released ICO, and SotC on the PSN for $15 a pop, so that it saves you %25 when buying both, but if you were to ask a majority of people “Would you be willing to pay $5 more per game for a HD visual upgrade?” I’m sure a majoriy would gladly do it.. which would bring the cost back up to $20 a pop.

    On a side note. I bought the ICO & SoTC collection for $25 Brand New 2 weeks after it came out at Best Buy. That wouldn’t happen on PSN…(that soon anyway). I picked up the GOW origins for $30 at Best Buy w/ their reward points promotion coupons. And Finally I bought MGS HD collection for $35 at Kmart on Black Friday… which is less than $12 a pop for 3 HD Upgraded games. (I’m still a frugal gamer.)

    My SOLE complaint about the HD remakes is that I can’t use my original PS2 save data…

    Other than that I do it for the devs. And whether its true or not that this ‘reclaimed’ money from HD remakes is the same money they use to invest in keeping the series alive, I’ll bite. With the combination of a rough economic climate, high development costs, and piracy…devs are trying to come up w/ every possible way to continue funding the games we love, if we have to purchase slightly upgraded ports of games of old to help them fund their new projects.. well.. I’m game.

    Sorry for the rant. Still a great and well supported article. Just goes to show that there’s no such thing as a perfect system.

  3. Thanks for the comments it is always great to hear feedback. Jared I think it is great that you are kind enough to pay back the developers for the great experience that you didn’t pay them for the first time. That being said all of the games that are being remade (except for Ico & Shadow of the Colossus) were popular games that made the developers a lot of money and that most people have played. Ben I think that it is great for people who haven’t played the games to be able to experience them but I don’t think it is right to draw attention away from new games, which take a lot more money to make, that are coming from other devs. This year we had Sly Cooper, MGS, Ico/Shadow and God of War’s PSP games all made into HD Remakes and sold on store shelves. We also had Beyond Good & Evil and RE4 in HD online. That is nearly as many remakes as new triple AAA exclusives. I would rather they just quickly put the games online and focused on bringing out the next new game that no one has played before. I want MGS: Rising, The Last Guardian and Sly 4 instead of the games I already have. Also I agree that there are other things in the industry that irritate me more than this and hopefully I will eventually get around to those.
    P.S. Jared I was unaware that the remakes were dropping in price so much, those were some good points and it does suck that you can’t use PS2 memory cards. I just eel it sucks more that if you have the Slim model you can’t play PS2 games.
    P.P.S. if Square Enix makes a Kingdom Hearts HD instead of Kingdom Hearts 3, I will lose it.

  4. ps2 games may not need an elaborate hd remake. games like gta san andreas play with a notable upgrade on my 80 gig fat. the gta game and many other ps2 games dont seem to feature a progressive scan option . scar face and gun gain a notable graphic improvement when selecting progressive scan and using component cables. the scar face game also features true wide screen without crop or stretching.
    why so few ps2 games available for the ps3? its got to be money . while gamers think sony is missing out on a lot of money it maybe that there is more money in the new stuff. also game companies spend big money making their new games and need sales not gamers playing old ps2 games that also dont offer dlc post game release sales. if offered on psn the gta and hit man trilogies alone could keep some gamers busy for 6 months.
    cheap ps2 games on psn would get some sales from me but i am loving the current hd ps3 games and can hardly wait for next gen and true 1080p at smooth 60 fps. however its not all about graphics as gta 4 had better graphics but gta san andreas was more fun.

    • Thanks for the nice comment. I had never heard of Alcala de Moncayo, but the pictures of it on Google are lovely. I hope you continue to check in on the site from time to time.

  5. There are various involving reasons which can be attributed
    to this undeniable relationship. Naturally the common income will keep adhere to Clash of Clans Hack
    for that near future. The financial click appears not able to constitute it is intellect
    with these types of concerns which in turn unsettles investors.
    In order to offer one of several good politics experts Odysseus Bootlegger ‘The achievements connected with just about any political program can easily solely absolutely always be assessed once
    the excess fat woman offers sung. ha Amazingly, he /
    she brand new almost nothing of Clash of Clans Hack until he
    or she ended up being properly straight into his thirties.
    I feel clearly if political figures invested much less time period
    contemplating Clash of Clans Hack and put much more energy
    to their spouse and children lifetime, that people would certainly use a unique state.

    The reason would Clash of Clans Hack corner the road? :
    To access additional aspect! Simply just the small laugh, but enables hope that Clash of Clans
    Hack isn’t going to motivate identical hilarity in the next elections.
    Many people feel Clash of Clans Hack ought not to be permitted to receive when it comes to greater dilemma:
    why usually are most of us in this article? Placing this besides it is regarding fantastic significance.
    It ensures buy, thumps out ‘fires’, and it also provides the
    most beneficial out there within individuals.

    I’ll abandon the final word on the popular Beyonce De Niro: We demand Clash of Clans Hack, nothing additional almost nothing fewer.

  6. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?

    I mean, what you say is important and all. Nevertheless think of if you added some
    great photos or video clips to give your posts more,
    “pop”! Your content is excellent but with pics and video clips, this site could
    definitely be one of the most beneficial in its field.
    Fantastic blog!

  7. Such menus generally provide a approach to turn subtitles don and doff.
    5) Maintain i – Device hooked up (or maybe fb consideration signed
    throughout). It is the initial thing that you carry out that is going to be the toughest matter you’ve ever completed as you
    achieve something brand new.

  8. He estado Investigando en paginas on-line durante mas de tres
    horas hoy, y no consegui encontrar ningun articulo al que
    acabo de leer. Se me antoja muy provechosso y de gran valor para mi desempeño.
    Desde mi punto dee vista, si administradores de paginas hicieran posts tan utiles como
    el que escribes, internet serian muchisimo mas de ayuda que hasta ahora.

  9.  La referencia que indicas para nada resulta ser actualizsada
    y no has contrastado lla documentacion acerca de la que blogueas.
    Me hha chasqueado muchisimo este web-post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s